Karen Read Trials – Jury Evidence Table (ChatGPT-3.5)

#	Fact / Item	1st Trial 2024 Prosecution	1st Trial 2024 Defense	Retrial 2025 Prosecution	Retrial 2025 Defense
1	John O’Keefe found outside 34 Fairview Rd ~6 a.m., 29 Jan 2022	Read reversed Lexus, struck him.¹	Beaten inside; body staged.²	Same.¹	Same.²
2	Head injuries & abrasions	Match vehicle impact.¹	Dog bites/assault.²	Same collision theory.¹	Same assault theory.²
3	Broken taillight fragments	Physical match Lexus.³	Planted/broke later.²	Same.³	Same chain‑of‑custody attack.²
4	Vehicle data reverse 24 mph	Purposeful strike.⁴	Data ambiguous.⁵	Same.⁴	Same challenge.⁵
5	“I hit him” statement	Confession.⁶	Question, not confession.⁶	Same testimony.⁶	Same rebuttal.⁶
6	Google search timing	6 :23 a.m.⁷	2 :27 a.m.⁸	Expert: 6 :24 a.m.⁷	Defense still 2 :27.⁸
7	Apple Health step data	Phone stayed in car.⁹	Victim walked inside.⁹	Analyst: phone yard.⁹	Step-count anomaly.⁹
8	Snow‑plow driver saw nothing	Visibility poor.¹⁰	Supports staging.¹⁰	Same, state downplays.¹⁰	Same staging use.¹⁰
9	Leaf‑blower & Solo‑cup evidence	Storm exigency.¹¹	Sloppy collection.¹¹	Officers repeat.¹¹	Contamination claim.¹¹
10	52 calls & 8 voicemails	Jealous rage.¹²	Frantic search.¹²	Audio played.¹²	Alcohol context.¹²
11	BAC up to 0.28 %	Extreme impairment.¹³	Speculative calc.¹³	Same toxicologist.¹³	Cross on limits.¹³
12	Read–Higgins texts	—	—	Jealousy motive.¹⁴	Third‑party culprit.¹⁴
13	Trooper Proctor vulgar texts	Irrelevant.¹⁵	Bias/cover‑up.¹⁵	State concedes.¹⁵	Tainted probe.¹⁵
14	Missing sneaker & shard	Impact debris.¹⁶	Planted/sloppy.¹⁶	Same.¹⁶	Same.¹⁶
15	Video timestamp error	Clerical.¹⁷	Manipulation.¹⁷	State downplays.¹⁷	Destruction theme.¹⁷
16	Peggy O’Keefe testimony	—	—	Emotional motive.¹⁸	Limited fact value.¹⁸

Sources